• Athletics
  • Big Ed
  • Ed Tech
  • Educators
  • Elections
  • Federal Policy
  • Parents
  • Students
  • The Testing Industry

K-12 News Network's The Wire

K-12 News Network: People-Powered Public Education News

  • Budgets
  • Charter Schools
  • Federal Policy
  • School Districts
  • State Education Law
  • School Boards
You are here: Home / New York City / A Hopeful Sign? NYC Schools' Number Two a Teacher and Brown University Graduate

A Hopeful Sign? NYC Schools' Number Two a Teacher and Brown University Graduate

December 20, 2010 by K12NN Site Admin

Facebooktwitterredditlinkedinmail

The appointment of Cathie Black as Joel Klein’s replacement for Chancellor of NYC schools set off a firestorm of resistance from teachers and parents who bristled at her corporate media background. As part of an uneasy truce and in recognition of her total lack of familiarity with the workings of public education, NY’s mayor appointed Shael Polakow-Suransky “Chief Academic Officer” as her number two.

What kind of response did that garner from NY parents and educators? Reflexive disgruntlement? Pre-emptive grumbling?

I had to chuckle when I read the NYT’s opening ‘graphs describing Polakow-Suransky’s own educational experience: a Brown University graduate? As someone who graduated from the nose-to-the-grindstone Cornell, we were always amazed that Brown allowed you to opt out of grades and was still considered part of the Ivy League. You heard me. In 1969, the “Brown Curriculum” instituted pass/fail classes and narrative evaluations; it seems only recently that students are able to choose conventional letter grades as well as Satisfactory/No Credit.

Mr. Polakow-Suransky spent his own high school years at a place called “Commie High”–a loving jibe at Community High School’s “experimental structure” in the college town of Ann Arbor, MI. His parents are both professors–faculty brat two times over. (I say this as a faculty brat myself.)

Hello? Have we forgotten how to decipher code words for “raised by hippies”? I think it’s possible that Polakow-Suransky says students need more testing, but qualitatively better testing along with quantity. And frankly, I’m heartened by an educator who believes those tests should consist of asking students to

“…write research papers, ask them to solve unfamiliar problems, ask them to defend their ideas, ask them to engage with both fiction and nonfiction texts; until those kinds of assessments are our state assessments, all we’re measuring are basic skills,” Mr. Polakow-Suransky said in an interview.

A sad, unattractive truth of standardized testing, however: bubbled-in scores on a machine-scanned test are easy to grade, and thus multiple choice tests are well-adapted to getting data back on large numbers of students.

Portfolios of journals/performances/3D models, open-ended math questions in which you show your work, lab journal results of experiments, drafts of re-written papers leading up to the polished draft, narrative self-evaluations as well as ones written by the teacher–these are all much more labor- and time-intensive to grade. Good, serious teachers prefer them and spend hours assessing their students’ work, but let’s not kid ourselves at the amount of time involved.

I think it’s honorable of Polakow-Suransky to broaden how we assess students in an effort to measure their ability at a higher level (beyond “basic skills”). But it very likely means squeezing more out of already stretched teachers if class sizes remain at 40 students per teacher. And that’s a recipe for disaster.

Quality student work, measured by quality assessments, will work best when there’s a reasonable class size. Otherwise, the sheer scale of students who need to be evaluated will push teachers and administrators to use standardized tests. Teaching is a hand-made, artisanal craft. We demand that it occur at machine-like speeds and scales. And I’d like to see Polakow-Suransky’s response to that reality.

Facebooktwitterlinkedinrssyoutube

Filed Under: New York City, School Districts Tagged With: NYC

About K12NN Site Admin

I'm Cynthia Liu, Owner/Founder of K12 News Network. I'm the proud product of public schools through post-grad, the mom of a child in public schools, and the daughter of two teachers. Connect with me professionally on LinkedIn.

Sign up for our newsletter

* indicates required
Email Format

Buy a hybrid Facebook+ website today!

Federal Policy

Quick Education Voter’s Guide to the California CD34 Race, April 4, 2017

There are twenty-three candidates running to fill former Congressman Xavier Bacerra’s seat in Congressional District 34 in Southern California. (Bacerra is currently the state’s Attorney General, replacing Kamala Harris, who, after November 8, 2016, became our US Senator.) Election Day is Tuesday, April 4, 2017, 7:00 am to 8:00 pm. You can find your polling […]

Betsy DeVos, #NOTMYSDOE

Take the pledge to #resist and fight for public schools as a public good TODAY. DeVos had to have the assistance of Vice President Mike Pence’s unprecedented tie-breaking vote in order to win her confirmation. Two GOP Senators voted against, all Democratic Senators voted against. Yet all the other GOP Senators who received campaign donations […]

Next #DemDebate MUST Include K-12 Education Policy

The next #DemDebate is scheduled for the important primary state of Iowa on November 14, 2015. It’ll be broadcast by CBS in partnership with the Des Moines Register. Professor Julian Vasquez Heilig is leading the call for the families of 50 million students K-12 across the nation and the communities they live in to have […]

More Posts from this Category

K12NN on Blog Talk Radio

Online Politics Progressive Radio at Blog Talk Radio with MOMocrats on BlogTalkRadio

Categories

December 2010
S M T W T F S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  
« Sep   Jan »

Copyright © 2022 · The Wire Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in